At the first General Congregation of the Synod for the Middle East this morning, Benedict XVI condemned the scourge of terrorism in the name of God. Antonios Naguib, Patriarch of Alexandria of the Copts, Egypt, relator general of the Synod, also gave an opening address and later gave a briefing to journalists. As expected, religious freedom appears to be at the forefront of discussions.
(Vatican City) - During the first General Congregation of the Special Assembly of the Synod of Bishops for the Middle East, held this morning in the Synod Hall, Pope Benedict XVI made some brief opening remarks in which he recalled how on this day, 11 October, in the year 1962, Pope John XXIII officially opened Vatican Council II.
But he also took the opportunity to condemn, in off-the-cuff remarks, the scourge of terrorist ideologies, emphasizing that those who cling to violence in the name of God are following false deities which will eventually fall. Terrorists’ destructive power can be carried out in the name of God, the Pope said, but he added: “It is not God: they are false gods that must be unmasked.”
As well as terrorist ideologies, he also singled out other idols such as drug abuse that “devours human lives like a beast”, as well as “a widespread view of marriage that no longer values the virtue of chastity”. He also spoke of “anonymous” economic interests that, instead of belonging to man, enslave and even massacre people.
The Pope explained that in the time of the early Church, the blood of martyrs weakened such false gods, beginning with the divine emperor and such false deities. “It is the blood of the martyrs, the pain, the cry of the Mother Church that makes them fall and so transform the world” – a process, he said, which “is never finished.”
Also addressing the first Congregation were Cardinal Leonardo Sandri, prefect of the Congregation for the Oriental Churches and president delegate on duty, Archbishop Nikola Eterovic, secretary general of the Synod of Bishops, and His Beatitude Antonios Naguib, Patriarch of Alexandria of the Copts, Egypt, relator general of the synod. The Patriarch read his "Relatio ante disceptationem", (report before the discussion).
Patriarch Naguib later gave a press conference to journalists at the Vatican, along with Chaldean Bishop Antoine Audo SJ of Alep, Syria. As expected, religious freedom appears to be at the forefront of discussions. The Patriarch said that freedom of conscience is “not so much a right to be claimed for Christians,” but a “universal right, which Christians and Muslims defend together for the common good.” He said it was important that Christians emerge defending only the rights of Christians, and engage in the defence of the rights of all.
One of the first questions the Patriarch was asked related to the news over the weekend of the Israeli government’s decision to enforce a new loyalty oath. The measure, which was approved by the cabinet, means all non-Jews who want to become citizens of Israel must now pledge loyalty to “a Jewish democratic” state. Critics say the decision, which will now go before the Knesset for approval, is a racist measure.
It will not apply to Jews who migrate to Israel nor affect current citizens, including the Israeli Arab community, but it is expected mainly to affect Palestinians living in the West Bank who want to marry Palestinians who live in Israel, who are known by the Israeli government as Israeli Arabs.
Patriarch Naguib said the decision was “contradictory”. “You cannot publicly proclaim that you are a democratic, a civil state and then impose on people to swear loyalty to this state, because that is a matter of personal religious choice,” he said. “That would not be logical or reasonable but in my opinion contradictory.”
He said it is “quite curious this has come from a state which declares itself as most democratic state - even the only democratic state - in the Arab region. In my opinion that’s patently contradictory [and] makes no sense.”
Turning to his native Egypt, the Patriarch acknowledged that Egyptian Christians are a small minority (only one in ten of the population) which makes the situation “peculiar”. It is therefore difficult for Christians to be adequately represented in all sections of society, he said. But he did not accept they were being persecuted. “Persecution implies there are rules and regulations, laws and decrees, that regulate the treatment and behaviour of Christians – this is not the case,” he explained.
Responding to a question asking for clarification on how the Synod will approach the issue of Church and State, Bishop Audo stressed the importance of differentiating between a positive lay status (one which separates the roles of religion and state yet respectful of religious values) and a negative lay status (one which regulates without reference to natural and divine law). The challenge, with which Lebanon has shown some success, is building a civil lay status while respecting religious values, he said.
Responding to a question on disputes in his native Lebanon, Bishop Audo said Christian divisions over politics are closely related to Muslim divisions – namely between Sunnites and Shiites. “Some have chosen to support Sunnites, others Shiites, while others consider relations should be good with both without being entrapped by a regional political axis,” he said. He added it was a “difficult situation” affecting the wider Middle East, but he said it was “good for society” to have a “multitude of opinions.”
On the liturgies taking place during the Synod, Patriarch Naguib said that on each day a different Eastern rite will lead the readings. Today, the liturgy was from the Latin rite, tomorrow it will be the turn of the Copts.
The Israeli government and Rabbi David Rosen of the American Jewish Committee have criticized comments made by Archbishop Cyrille Salim Bustros during the release of the final message of the Synod on Saturday. The Vatican has not issued an official statement in response to the archbishop’s words, but stressed that “a concise expression of the positions of the Synod” can be found in the final message.
Pope Benedict XVI has closed the two week Synod of bishops on the Middle East with words of encouragement for the region’s Christians and a strong plea for peace. In his homily to the synod fathers in St. Peter’s basilica Oct. 24, the Pope called on Christians of the Middle East to do “their part in the spirit of the Beatitudes” and be “builders of peace and apostles of reconciliation” for the benefit of society.
The Synod on the Middle East was a “new Pentecost”, a time of “hope, strength and resolution” which the synod fathers aim to bring back to their churches in the region. These were the words from the ‘Nuntius’, or ‘Message to the People of God’ at the conclusion of the Oct. 10-24 meeting.
“We should thank the Lord who gave us this opportunity and grace to be able to reconvene here this first Synod on the Middle East in history.” These were the words of Coptic Patriarch Antonios Naguib, the relator general of the Synod, at a press conference Oct. 23, marking the conclusion of the Synod and the presentation of the final messsage and propositions.
Italian Father Francesco Patton OFM was born on December 23rd, 1963. He belongs to the Franciscan Province of St. Anthony in Italy. He is fluent in English and Spanish, besides his native Italian.
The account of Tommaso Saltini, director of the NGO ATS - Pro Terra Sancta, on his return from Syria. Some of the ways the funds allocated by the Custody, including thanks to the generosity of readers, are used.
Save Israel-Stop the Occupation (SISO) aims to serve as an umbrella-movement for individuals and organizations who consider Israel’s on-going rule over occupied Palestinian territory disastrous.
Pope Francis will be on Lesbos on Saturday 16th April, with the ecumenical patriarch of Constantinople, Bartholomew, to meet the refugees. Father John Luke Gregory brings us up to date from Rhodes and Kos.